To content
Department of Spatial Planning

RTBM publication

© Pexels:Pixabay
New FRESH publication: Will consumers return e-commerce packaging?

A new study from the FRESH project has been published in Research in Transportation Business & Management. The authors are Furqan A. Bhat (TU Dortmund), Anna Reiffer and Eva Heinen (ETH Zürich).

Online shopping keeps growing, and so do parcel volumes and the packaging waste that comes with them. Reusable packaging can reduce this waste, but only if consumers return it. Without enough returns, even well-designed systems cannot recover their costs. The study therefore asks how willing consumers are to return packaging, and whether that depends on how the return works.

Three return mechanisms were compared:

  • Central collection: consumers drop the packaging off at a designated point.

  • Back mailing: consumers send the packaging back by post.

  • Return during the next delivery: consumers hand the packaging back to the courier at their next delivery.

The study uses survey data from 2,012 respondents in Dortmund, Paris, Trondheim and Zurich. A hybrid multivariate ordered probit model jointly estimates attitudes, shopping behaviour, and acceptance of all three mechanisms.

Key findings

  • Returning packaging during the next delivery was the most widely accepted option. Between 62% and 65% of respondents in every city said they were likely or very likely to use it.

  • Central collection was also well accepted, but back mailing met clear resistance. In Paris, fewer than 40% of respondents were likely to use back mailing.

  • Willingness to return depended mainly on attitudes and habits. Environmental concern and shopping frequency raised acceptance of all three mechanisms. Age, gender, income and other socio-demographic characteristics mattered little, and mostly acted indirectly through attitudes and shopping behaviour.

  • City differences depended on the mechanism: back mailing was less accepted in Paris and central collection in Trondheim.

What this means
The results suggest that packaging return works best when it is built into deliveries consumers already receive, not added as an extra task. For logistics operators and cities, collecting packaging at the next delivery is the most promising way to achieve the return rates that reusable packaging requires. 

Read the full article: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rtbm.2026.101909